Governor-elect Rob Sand (@RobSandIA) waited four days to say anything about the Army’s plan to set off a lead bomb in southeast Iowa. When he finally did, he had nothing to offer but a press-release shrug. Since then? Crickets.
Here’s what happened. On Nov. 13, the EPA quietly issued an emergency permit letting the Army detonate degraded lead azide in place at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, a town of about 300 people near Burlington. On Nov. 15, the Army posted its public advisory: two controlled detonations at about noon on Friday, Nov. 20. The plan covered 68 barrels, roughly 9,700 pounds of an explosive that has recrystallized and become so sensitive to friction and shock that the Army says it can’t safely be moved.
The Army’s own advisory included a plume map warning of toxic lead dust settling to the north, with children under six “especially vulnerable.” Residents near Middletown City Park were told to clear out from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. ISU Extension told cattle producers to pull livestock off pasture and ponds and to watch for signs of lead poisoning, starting with “sudden death.” Gov. Kim Reynolds’ office says it learned of the plan Monday, Nov. 16.
Iowa had the whole weekend and most of the week to hear from the man about to take over the Statehouse. It got nothing.
Thursday morning, 11:35 a.m.
Sand finally posted at 11:35 a.m. Central on Thursday, Nov. 19. That was about four days after the Army’s advisory, six days after the EPA permit, and barely 24 hours before the scheduled blast. Here it is in full:
Read it twice. Safety should be the “top concern.” Iowans are “understandably concerned.” The public “deserves to know.” Swap “lead azide” for a bridge closure or a boil order and every word still works. No mention of Middletown. No mention of the farmers, the cattle, the water, or the kids in the plume path. No demand of the Army, the EPA, or anyone in Washington. And not one idea of his own.
The last line is the tell: if it isn’t as safe as possible, it shouldn’t happen. That’s a hedge, not a position. It lets him say he called for a pause if the blast goes badly and say he never opposed the Army if it goes fine.
Where was Rob? Deer Valley, Utah.
Here’s the part that should make every Iowan in the plume path furious. While southeast Iowa was pulling kids out of school and moving cattle off pasture, Sand was at a ski resort in Utah. On Nov. 19, the same day as his three-paragraph statement and the day before the blast was supposed to go off, he sat for an onstage interview at the POLITICO Pub at the National Governors Association’s New Governors Leadership Forum in Deer Valley, Utah. What made news? Not Middletown. POLITICO’s headline: “Rob Sand shuts down any talk of 2028.” A second POLITICO video promises Sand talking about his “model past.”
MAHA activist Kelly Ryerson (@GlyphosateGirl) noticed. At 11:20 p.m. Friday, she asked the question a lot of Iowans were already asking:
Forty minutes later she followed up, saying Sand had “been busy hanging at a Politico event in Deer Valley instead. As people in the state are very alarmed and evacuating.” POLITICO’s own coverage backs her up on where he was.
And since that Thursday statement? Sand’s X feed has a tribute to the late Sen. Wally Horn, a salute emoji, and on Saturday morning a string of jokey replies, one asking “Red hair, Niles?” and another calling something “the nicest thing anyone has ever said about me.” On the barrels in Middletown, not one new word.
Lahn was there first, with a plan
Zach Lahn doesn’t hold office. He lost this race. He was still out ahead of the governor-elect anyway.
At 8:47 p.m. Central on Wednesday, Nov. 18, roughly 15 hours before Sand said a word, Lahn went after the official line that lead dust can just be hosed off and stays “below levels of concern”:
At 9:38 a.m. Thursday, still two hours before Sand, he cut straight to it:
“When farmers have to keep cattle inside, off the water and grass, it’s clearly gone too far. We can catch a 250-ton rocket with chopsticks, but can’t dispose of an explosive without 100-mile neurotoxin plume? Pause, bring in the brightest minds, find another way.”
Then at 5:07 p.m. Thursday he did what Sand never did and laid out an actual plan. Lahn said he’d talked with people who know the situation, including officials in Washington, and he didn’t pretend there was a magic answer: “an unplanned detonation would clearly be the worst option.” He pointed out that the stockpile has reportedly been known about since 2004 with nothing done. Then he got specific:
Plan as if we’re going to detonate anyway. Keep every precaution in place.
Send in a robot instead of a person. Lahn proposed using an Optimus robot from @elonmusk to open each barrel and apply a chemical neutralizer like ceric ammonium nitrate, a documented way to break lead azide down into nitrogen gas, with nobody in harm’s way.
Accept that every outcome beats the status quo. Best case, it’s all neutralized and there’s no blast. Middle case, the blast is smaller. Worst case, a barrel goes off with every precaution already in place.
Make the Army pause. “The Army should pause tomorrow’s detonation long enough to think up crazy ideas that just may work.”
His bottom line: “Just going ahead as planned without trying to find a way to protect people, land, water, and soil is not an acceptable way to think about this.”
Call the robot idea a moonshot. Lahn did himself. It’s still a real idea. Sand’s contribution was a vibe. And for the record, the Army’s own environmental assessment rejected chemical neutralization because it would mean workers handling the drums for days or weeks. Taking the humans out of that equation is exactly the problem Lahn’s idea is aimed at.
Still working the phones
Lahn didn’t post once and move on. Nine minutes before midnight on Friday, he answered Ryerson directly:
“One of the main reasons I ran is because I truly care about the health of our state. An election outcome doesn’t change that,” he wrote, adding that he’d “been on the phone w/officials in the WH tonight trying to help find other options.”
At 9:34 a.m. Saturday he posted an update. By Lahn’s account, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (@seckennedy) called him Friday night about his “deep concern” over the detonation, then connected him with Vice President JD Vance’s team and the White House, both of whom called late that night. Lahn says he can “say with certainty that they are looking at every available alternative.” He also says a former senior Defense Department official with decades in weapons threat reduction sent him an analysis, now shared with those offices, recommending an independent review by one of the National Laboratories to determine how urgent the threat really is. “If time allows,” Lahn wrote, “there are indeed other options available to mitigate the risk.”
That’s the difference. One guy lost the election and is calling the White House at midnight to find another way. The other guy won it, put out one statement, and went back to talking about 2028 and his hair.
Where it stands
Thursday evening, Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle pushed the blast to Monday, Nov. 23, calling it the “latest possible moment” before colder weather destabilizes the material further. Late Thursday night, the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals issued a temporary administrative stay of the EPA permit at the request of the Iowa Environmental Council and Sierra Club Iowa. As of Saturday, that stay is still in place.
But don’t relax yet. On Friday, Justice Department lawyers representing the EPA told the court they’ll fight the stay, with a full response due by Sunday. They also pointed to an EPA rule that lets the Army treat waste without a permit in a qualifying emergency. Earthjustice, which represents the environmental groups, called that “an extraordinary and extreme backstop” and urged the Army not to use it. The Army hasn’t said whether it will. Friday evening, Gov. Reynolds activated the State Emergency Operations Center. And on Saturday, the City of Fort Madison said it had been told the Army will “most likely” detonate on Monday, Nov. 23, or Tuesday, Nov. 24. So the Monday date may still be live, court stay or not.
For now, those barrels are still sitting in Middletown.
Southeast Iowa deserved a governor-elect who showed up early with answers. On this one, the guy who lost the race showed up first, and he’s still working the problem. Rob Sand showed up with talking points, then spent the day at a Utah ski resort talking about himself.